Species keys (arranged alphabetically by genus)
1a.
Protoconch surface smooth; ribs weak, irregular; spiral color bands present
A. kochi
1b.
Protoconch with distinct cross-hatching; ribs strong, regular; color bands (if present) transverse
2a.
Shell height >½ shell diameter; 3+ ribs per mm on body whorl
A. alternata
2b.
Shell height <½ shell diameter; 2½ or fewer ribs per mm on body whorl
A strongyloides
1a.
Shell width 2/5 of height
C. exiguum
1b.
Shell width 1/3 of height
2a.
Shell surface completely smooth
2b.
Shell surface distinctly striate
3a.
Shell height >1.5 mm; body whorl distinctly wider than penultimate
C. riparium
3b.
Shell height <1.5 mm; body and penultimate whorls of approximately same diameter
C. nannodes
4a.
Striae strong with sharp edges, peristome unthickened
C. clappi
4b.
Striae weaker with rounded edges, peristome moderately thickened
C. exile
1a.
Shell >1.9 times as tall as broad, color light red-tan, resticted to fens
C. exile
1b.
Shell <1.8 times as tall as broad, color grey-green to tan, habitats various
2a.
Shell averaging >7mm tall, growth lines indistinct; tan-brown color; moist, open habitats
C. avara
2b.
Shells averaging <7mm tall, growth lines relatively distinct, gray-green color
C. wandae / C. gelida
*Note: Species differentiation in this genus is problematic, as is true for all Succineads.
Dissection of putative C. 'gelida' from northeastern Iowa indicates that this taxon is conspecific
with C. wandae. As holotype C. gelida is Pleistocene fossil material likely representing
Oxyloma verrilli, C. wandae is the correct name for the extant Midwestern populations.
1a.
Mature shells >2.3 mm wide, broadly ovate shape
C. lubrica
1b.
Mature shells < 2.3 mm wide, elliptical shape
2a.
Mature shells <6 mm tall; deep suture with rounded whorls; shell translucent brown
C. lubricella
2b.
Mature shells >6 mm tall; shallow suture with flattened whorls; shell transparent, yellow
C. morseana
1a.
Shell cylindrical; apex domed; adult shell with 6-7 whorls, >2½mm tall
C. columella alticola
1b.
Shell tapered; apex conical; adult shell with 5½-6½ whorls, <=2½mm tall
C. simplex
* Note: Many races of C. simplex exist which may eventually be found to represent distinct
species. One of the most striking has approximately the same height as C. columella alticola, yet
possesses the conical shape of C. simplex for the upper 1/3 of the shell. This form ranges from the
mountains of the desert SW eastward through the upper Midwest into New England, and is typically limited to
wooded carbonate rock outcrops.
1a.
Lamella present on columellar side of aperture
D. patulus
1b.
Lamella absent
2a.
Ribs indistinct or lacking on shell base
2b.
Ribs distinct on shell base
3a.
Umbilicus >1/3 shell diameter
D. macclintocki
3b.
Umbilicus 1/3 shell diameter or less (Pleistocene fossil only in the upper Midwest)
D. shimekii
4a.
Angular body whorl margin
D. catskillensis
4b.
Rounded body whorl margin
D. cronkhitei
*Note: Though D. catskillensis and D. cronkhitei populations are often easily separated
in some places within the Upper Midwest, across much of northern Minnesota, Wisconsin, Michigan and adjacent
areas of Ontario they are not. As a result, they may not represent distinct species. In addition, the
distinction between D. cronkhitei and Eurasian D. ruderatus has never been clearly demonstrated,
making it plausible that these represent a single Holarctic species. In this case, D. ruderatus has
taxonomic priority.
1a.
Whorls gradually increasing in size, with last 3 constituting <2/3 of total shell diameter as
seen from top; spiral lines cutting through stirae on protochonch
E. polygyratus
1b.
Whorls increasing rapidly in size, with last 3 constituting >2/3 of total shell diameter as
seen from top; distinct ribs and spiral lines present on initial whorls
2a.
Protochonch luster shiny with reduced striation; dark brown-copper colored; spiral lines
on base as or more distinct than transverse lines
E. alderi
2b.
Protochonch luster silky with crisp striation; tan to light-brown color; spiral lines
on base less distinct than transverse lines
E. fulvus
1a.
Shell <3¼mm tall; ovoid-conical; color white to brown
1b.
Shell >3¼mm tall, cylindrical or barrel-shaped; translucent white when fresh (subgenus
Albinula)
2a.
Angulo-parietal lamella a simple peg-like tooth
2b.
Angulo-parietal lamellae not peg-shaped
3a.
Angulo-parietal lamella a single large, folded sheet
G. contracta
3b.
Angular and parietal lobes of angulo-parietal lamellae distinct
4a.
Fresh shells whitish
4b.
Fresh shells brown-red
5a.
Columellar lamella triangular or round in cross section
5b.
Columellar lamella a more or less vertical, folded plate
G. similis
6a.
Columellar lamella with both forward and basally pointing components, appearing
more or less pyramidal in apertural view; shell usually >4 mm tall
G. armifera
6b.
Columellar lamella lacking a basal lobe, making the entire structure appear as a
downward-pointing peg in apertural view; shell <4 mm tall
G. abbreviata
7a.
Shell narrowly conical, with height more than 1� times width; lower palatal lamella deeply entering aperture
G. pentodon
7b.
Shell broadly conical, with height less than 1� times width; lower palatal lamella not deeply entering aperture
G. tappaniana
8a.
Basal and palatal lamellae absent; shell >2.4 mm tall
G. corticaria
8b.
Basal and palatal lamellae present; shell <2.0 mm tall
G. holzingeri
9a.
Angular lobe separate and parallel to parietal lobe throughout
G. rogersensis
9b.
Angular lobe pointed towards and fused to the middle of the parietal lobe
G. procera
1a.
Shell openly umbilicate
1b.
Shell very narrowly rimate
G. indentata
2a.
Shell with evenly-spaced impressed ribs, color clear-white, spiral striation absent
G. rhoadsi
2b.
Shell with irregular impressed ribs, color honey-yellow, spiral striations present
G. wheatleyi
1a.
Callus thickening present inside of shell
Hawaiia n. sp.
1b.
No shell thickenings present inside of shell
H. minuscula
*Note: The status of these two taxa is not resolved. Individuals exhibiting a callus are not
limited to Upper Midwest fens as claimed by Frest, but also occur in Ozarks and Driftless Area riparian
forest.
1a.
Surface shiny and smooth or with microscopic spiral lines
1b.
Surface dull with large, raised spiral lyrae
2a.
Umbilicus deep (usually extending beyond ½ of shell height) and wide (½-1/3 of shell diameter) as seen in
mature individuals; somewhat domed spire
H. singleyanus
2b.
Umbilicus shallow (rarely extending beyond ½ of shell height) and narrow (1/3-¼ of shell diameter) as seen in
mature individuals; flat spire
H. inermis
3a.
Callus present inside shell without lamellae
Helicodiscus n. sp.
3b.
Lamellae present inside shell without callus
4a.
Body whorl width (on bottom) <1 mm wide; umbilicus very wide (>2/3 shell diameter) and shallow (<½ shell height)
H. shimeki
4b.
Body whorl width (on bottom) >=1 mm; umbilicus less wide (<2/3 shell diameter) and deeper (approximately ½
shell height)
H. parallelus
*Note: H. inermis and H. singleyanus appear very close, and may represent
ecophenotypes of the same species. The validity of Helicodiscus n.sp. of Frest is not clear, as
this form is not limited to fens, but is characteristic of grasslands and glades throughout the region.
It seems likely that its heavier callus could be an ecophenotypic response to open habitats.
1a.
Shell diameter >18 mm
M. thyroidus
1b.
Shell diameter <=18 mm
M. clausus
1a.
Umbilicus <1/10 shell width
1b.
Umbilicus >=1/10 shell width
2a.
Whorl and protoconch surface nearly smooth; glassy luster
M. inornatus
2b.
Whorl and protoconch striate; dull luster
3a.
Body whorl absent or with only indistinct spiral lines
M. vulgatus
3b.
Body whorl with distinct spiral lines
M. globosus
4a.
Umbilicus open, 1/5-1/6 shell diameter
M. cupreus
4b.
Umbillicus rimate, 1/7-1/10 shell diameter
M. friabilis
1a.
Shell with distinct spiral color bands
Webbhelix multilineata
1b.
Shell of uniform color
2a.
Diameter >20mm
2b.
Diameter <20mm
Patera pennsylvanica
3a.
Parietal lamellae >1/3 aperture length, shell almost as tall as wide
Mesodon elevatus
3b.
Parietal lamellae <1/3 aperture length or absent, shell clearly wider than tall
4a.
Parietal lamella present; final 3 whorls constituting <80% of shell diameter
Mesodon zaletus
4b.
Parietal lamella absent; final 3 whorls constituting 80% or more of shell diameter
5a.
Pronounced thickening on peristome base near columella
Neohelix alleni
5b.
Peristome thickness essentially constant throughout
Neohelix albolabris
1a.
Shell brown, >4½mm diameter at 4½ whorls
N. electrina
1b.
Shell whitish, <4mm diameter at 4½ whorls
N. binneyana
O. strigosa cooperi (in Upper Midwest, a Pleistocene fossil
only)
1a.
Width of final segment of body whorl 2x that of adjacent section of penultimate whorl; shell diameter generally >11mm;
shell luster not too glossy
O. draparnaudi
1b.
Width of final segment of body whorl ~1.5x of adjacent section of penultimate whorl; shell diameter generally <11mm;
glassy shell luster
O. cellarius
1a.
Penultimate whorl (as seen from bottom) low convex, with maximum width <=½ the maximum aperture width;
aperture approaching maximum width in upper ½ of shell
O. salleanum
1b.
Penultimate whorl (as seen from bottom) more highly convex, with maximum width 2/3-¾ of the maximum aperture
width; aperture approaching maximum width at ½ of shell height
2a.
Shell width >½ of shell height; shell apex angle >75° (e.g. 3 shells lined up like pie wedges with apices
touching makes more than ½ of a circle)
O. peoriensis
2b.
Shell width <=½ of shell height; shell apex angle approximately 60° (e.g. 3 shells lined up like pie wedges
with apices touching makes ½ of a circle or less)
O. retusum
*Note: this genus, along with all Succineads, is taxonomically challenging, with the species
concept being unresolved and taxa being largely unseparable based on shell characteristics. O.
peoriensis looks very much like a small Succinea, and individuals may also key out in that genus.
In the Succinea key, it will key out as S. indiana, with whom it will differ based upon it
wetland rather than xeric upland habitat, and its smooth, clear shell (rather than roughened, translucent
shells in S. indiana)
1a.
Lamellae consisting of separate pegs
P. multidentata
1b.
Individual lamellae fused into a single callus ridge
Paravitrea multidentata form lamellata
1a.
Umbilicus <¼ shell diameter, rimate; hairs on shell surface
Daedalochila leporina
1b.
Umbilicus >1/3 shell diameter, shells without hairs
2a.
Margin of shell angular
Daedalochila fatigata
2b.
Margin of shell rounded
3a.
Upper palatial lamella deeply immersed; parietal lamella with straight-sided, angular channel down middle and a
tri-lobed terminus
Daedalochila plicata
3b.
Upper palatial lamella only moderately immersed; parietal lamella with rounded, concave channel down middle and
with square terminus
Daedalochila dorfeulliana
*Note: It seems very likely that D. leporina should actually be assigned to the genus
Lobosculum based on a number of conchological criteria.
1a.
Shell approximately twice as tall as wide
P. lapidaria
1b.
Shell approximately 1.3 times as tall as wide
P. cincinnatiensis
1a.
Lamellae present on base of aperture
P. smithi
1b.
Lamellae absent
2a.
Umbilicus >1/3 shell diameter
P. blandianum
2b.
Umbilicus <=1/3 shell diameter
3a.
Shell >1.2 mm diameter and >¾ mm tall; color deep rust-brown
Punctum n.sp.
3b.
Shell <=1 mm diameter and <=½ mm tall; color tan to gray
4a.
All ribs of essentially equal size, spearated by 1-3 minor riblets
P. minutissimum
4b.
Some ribs more prominent than others, separated by 5+ minor riblets
P. vitreum
*Note: P. n. sp. of Frest appears closest to the high elevation West Coast P.
californicum, however it differs from that taxon by possessing a lower spire.
P. muscorum muscorum
*Note: This taxon represents a species complex which has not been adequately worked out in North
America. P. muscorum is present as a Eurasian exotic which has escaped throughout from New England
and the Rust Belt states west to eastern Iowa. The haplotypes for these populations are closest to those
reported from Sweden. In addition, an unknown number of native taxa have also been lumped under this name.
These are genetically highly distinct, and closest to P. hebes of the North American west and arctic
and P. pratensis of western Eurasia.
1a.
Lower margin of peristome complete (
Euchemotrema)
1b.
Lower margin of peristome with notch removed (
Stenotrema)
2a.
Shell margin angular
E. hubrichti
2b.
Shell margin rounded
3a.
Body and penultimate whorls >1¼ mm wide as measured from top of shell
E. fraternum
3b.
Body and penultimate whorls <=1¾ mm wide as measured from top of shell
4a.
Shell umbilicate; <8½ mm diameter
E. leai leai
4b.
Shell imperforate; >=9 mm diameter
E. leai aliciae
5a.
Right end of parietal lamella entering aperture; aperture less wide than basal peristome lip
S. stenotrema
5b.
Right end of parietal lamella barely entering aperture, aperture as wide as basal peristome lip
6a.
Aperture wider than basal peristome margin; shell >= 8 mm diameter; interior lamella at the junction of the columella
and aperture extending >1 mm beyond basal peristome margin; approximately 4 shell hairs per mm
S. barbatum
6b.
Aperture same width as basal peristome margin; shell approximately 6 mm diameter; interior lamella at the junction of
the columella and aperture extending <1 mm beyond basal peristome margin; 5-6 shell hairs per mm
S. hirsutum
1a.
Shell diameter <2mm
1b.
Shell diameter >2mm
2a.
Sprial lines prominent on protoconch
S. meridionalis
2b.
No sprial lines on protoconch
S. milium
3a.
Prominent, widely spaced ribs, umbilicus 1/3 diameter, whorls increasing slowly
S. exigua
3b.
Ribs and spiral lines weak, umbilicus 1/5 shell diameter or less; whorls increasing rapidly
S. ferrea
1a.
Margin angular, shell pyramidal, 3-4 basal folds
S. aeneus
1b.
Margin rounded, shell beehive-shaped, 5+ basal folds
2a.
Basal folds of equal size, arranged in smooth arc
S. affinis
2b.
Basal fold size unequal with second from umbilius much longer than first, folds arranged in an irregular arc
S. labyrinthicus
1a.
Shell apex angle >60°
1b.
Shell apex angle <60°
2a.
Mature shell length >15 mm; shell thin and usually translucent
S. ovalis group, including S. ovalis, S. n.sp.
Minnesota A and S. n.sp. Minnesota B, plus the Wisconsin cliff-dwelling taxon called 'S. bakeri'
by Frest
2b.
Mature shell length <15 mm
3a.
Shell surface irregular; shell thick and almost opaque
S. indiana group
3b.
Shell surface smooth; shell thin and transparent
Oxyloma peoriense
4a.
Mature shell length >15 mm
S. chittenangoensis
4b.
Mature shell length <15 mm
S. forsheyi
*Note: A notoriously difficult group, which has been extensively split into a number of taxa based
upon what appear to be trivial shell and anatomical differences. However, the shells are all convergent,
and given the plascticity of many of the genetalic traits, it is unclear what the biological species concept
in this genus is and how many of these proposed taxa are valid. This state of taxonomic affairs is
reminiscent of the confusion which surrounds the plant genus Rubus in North America. In his "Flora
of the Northeastern US and Canada", Henry Gleason states: "Species in the ordinary sense of the term scarcely
exist in the section Eubatus...... There have been produced in the American Brambles a large number,
possibly as many as 10,000, of small populations of microspecies, differing from each other very slightly,
although the culmination of minute differences leads to extremes which are quite unlike. .... In order to
keep the number of taxonomic groups within bounds and make them recognizable to the student, it has been
necessary to use only a limited number of combinations of characters, thereby segregating thirteen native
American groups which can be regarded as collective species. These are intended for convenience only."
This summary applies almost identically to the genus Succinea. Thus, like Gleason did with Rubus,
I have opted to designate in only 4 extant collective species-groups within Succinea to make this
group easier to deal with by ecological researchers.
1a.
Parietal lamella pointed below palatial
T. tridentata
1b.
Parietal lamella pointed at or above palatial
2a.
Shell surface smooth and shining; flat spire
T. discoidea
2b.
Shell surface striate and dull; domed spire
T. vulgata
1a.
Peristome unthickened in mature shells
V. perspectiva
1b.
Peristome strongly white-thickened in mature shells
2a.
Shell surface smooth, shiny, major ribs absent
2b.
Shell surface dull, major ribs present
3a.
Shell white; ribs low but distinct; diameter of minor axis in mature shells >1½ mm; body whorl diameter
remaining relatively constant at aperture so that last portion of whorl remains approximately parallel
to penultimate
V. pulchella
3b.
Shell yellow-tan; ribs indistinct or lacking, making shell appear smooth; diameter of minor axis in mature shells
<=1½ mm; body whorl diameter increasing rapidly at aperture so that last portion of whorl diverges
from penultimate
V. excentrica
4a.
Diameter of mature shells <=2mm
V. parvula
4b.
Diameter of mature shells >2mm
5a.
Diameter of mature shells <2½mm, 23-35 ribs on body whorl, ribs > 0.1 mm tall
V. costata
5b.
Diameter >2½mm, 45-50 ribs on body whorl, ribs <0.1 mm tall
V. gracilicosta
1a.
Umbilicus rimate, less than 1/10 shell diameter; shell diameter >6 mm
1b.
Umbilicus open, more than 1/10 shell diameter; shell diameter <6 mm
2a.
Basal lamellae present
V. gularis
2b.
Basal lamellae absent
3a.
Strong spiral striate on last whorl; shell surface dull below
V. intertextus
3b.
Spiral striae on last whorl indistinct, limited to base of whorl; shell surface glossy below
V. ligera
4a.
Palatial lamellae present
V. virginicus
4b.
Palatial lamellae absent
V. suppressus
1a.
Shell surface smooth or weakly striate
1b.
Shell surface strongly striate
2a.
Six or more apertural lamellae
2b.
Five or fewer apertural lamellae
3a.
Basal lamella absent
3b.
Basal lamella present
4a.
Parietal lamella pointed directly at lower palatal lamella, so that parietal, lower palatal, and columellar lamellae
form a cross; shell conical
V. meramecensis
4b.
Parietal lamella pointed at upper palatal or space between the upper and lower palatals; shell ovoid or columnar
5a.
Lower palatal lamella inserted near aperture margin so that only short axis is visible when seen in apertural view
5b.
Lower palatal lamella inserted more deeply into shell so that long axis is visible when seen in apertural view
6a.
Angular lamella absent; palatal wall with callus and light-colored crest; shell dull
V. pygmaea
6b.
Angular lamella present; crest not light-colored; shell shiny
7a.
Adult shell with ~6 whorls; aperture less than 1/3 of shell height
V. morsei
7b.
Adult shell with ~4 whorls; aperture 1/3 or more of shell height
8a.
Shell >2.0 mm tall; lower palatal lamella a straight blade
V. ovata
8b.
Shell <1.8 mm tall; lower palatal lamella curved and deeply entering aperture
V. milium
9a.
Three or four apertural lamellae
9b.
Five apertural lamellae
10a.
Shell height >2¼ mm
V. modesta modesta
10b.
Shell height <2¼ mm
11a.
Body whorl inflated, making shell height less than twice the width; shell color with slight greenish cast; distinct
spiral striation on body whorl; aperture margin usually dark olive-brown to black
V. perryi
11b.
Body whorl not greatly inflated, making shell height approximately twice the width; shell color honey-yellow;
no spiral striation on body whorl; aperture margin not darkened
V. tridentata
12a.
Shell >2¼ mm tall; angular lamella present
12b.
Shell <2¼ mm tall; angular lamella absent
13a.
Shell height less than twice the width, basal lamella present
V. ovata
13b.
Shell height twice the width or more, basal lamella absent
V. modesta form parietalis
14a.
Shell weakly striate; single depression behind aperture over both palatal lamellae
V. bollesiana
14b.
Shell smooth; separate slight depressions under each palatal lamellae, or none
15a.
Shell surface dull; strong crest; light-colored callus on palatal wall
V. pygmaea
15b.
Shell surface shiny; crest less prominent; callus of same color as shell
V. elatior
16a.
Shell >2¼ mm tall, shiny with weak striae
V. modesta modesta
16b.
Shell <=2¼ mm tall, shell dull with distinct striae
17a.
Shell shape conical with body whorl much wider than the penultimate; color deep cinnamon-red; crest absent; shell
striation irregular in strength and spacing
V. meramecensis
17b.
Shell shape ovate with body whorl approximately the same width as the penultimate; color yellow-red brown; crest
present; shell striation uniform
V. cristata
18a.
Striae indistinct, with shell often appearing smooth under low (x10) magnification; single deep depression over
both palatal lamellae; ~1¾ mm tall
V. bollesiana
18b.
Striae distinct, with shell not appearing smooth under low (x10) magnification; palatal depression weak or absent;
most forms >1¾ mm tall, with small southern Appalachian forms being ~1¾ mm tall
V. gouldii
19a.
Callus surrounding at least the upper palatal and often the entire palatal wall; ranging from eastern Ontario to
Alaska and south to New Mexico
V. arthuri form arthuri
19b.
Callus absent on palatal wall
20a.
Columellar lamella more massive than the parietal; angular lamella strong; lower palatal lamella so deeply inserted
that most of it is obscured by the columellar wall; striation fine and sharp
V. nylanderi
20b.
Parietal lamella more massive than the columellar; angular lamella weak or absent; lower palatal lamella less deeply
inserted so that most is observable in apertural view; striae somewhat rounded
21a.
Basal and weak angular lamellae often present; ranging from the Upper Mississippi River valley to eastern Ontario
V. arthuri form hubrichti
21b.
Basal and angular lamellae often absent; ranging from Newfoundland and central Manitoba to northern Minnesota,
northern Wisconsin and the New England states; also in Alaska and the Yukon
V. arthuri form paradoxa
1a.
Umbilicus covering over ¼ of shell diameter; upper surface dull, ribbed
Z. limatulus
1b.
Umbilicus covering less than 1/5 of shell diameter, upper surface shiny, ribless
2a.
Shell luster satiny from microscopic spiral lines; aperture elliptical; shell yellowish
Z. arboreus
2b.
Shell luster glassy, microscopic spiral lines absent; aperture round; shell rusty-brown
Z. nitidus